profitwell paddle

BIG NEWS: Paddle acquires ProfitWell to "do it for you"

How To: Burn the Churn

Neel Desai Apr 3 2019

On this episode of the ProfitWell Report, Nathan Beckord, Co-Founder and CEO of Foundersuite, wants to know the best ways to combat churn, and we think it's safe to assume Nathan isn't the only one on the churn-solving mission.

So to locate the best tactics to combat churn, we studied and gathered data from just over eight thousand subscription companies.

Here's what we found.



*****We will only be posting a few of these episodes on the blog, which means if you want to make sure you don't miss an episode of this series you must subscribe separately below****


Churn is a fact of life in the subscription game, but the beauty of the subscription model is that for the first time in the history of business, the relationship is baked right into how we make money. If a customer no longer sees the value in what we’re providing, they can easily cancel when the term comes up for renewal.

Yet, just because churn is a fact of life, doesn’t mean we can’t optimize for tactics that reduce churn considerably. Lets get to the data we gathered.

First up, the number one thing a lot of us need to attack yesterday is our failed payments.

Credit cards are mechanical devices subject to failure and delinquencies. Failed credit cards account for 20 to 40% of your churn when looking at both B2B and B2C companies. Note that as you get larger, the proportion of your churn that comes from delinquencies actually increases. 


Click to enlarge

This is likely because you’re getting a bit better at regular churn, but also because you don’t get economies of scale with more credit cards.

To make matters worse, we’re actually pretty bad at recovering these failed payments.

No matter the size of the company, we’re recovering only around 30% of those individuals that have a failed payment.


Click to enlarge

To put it another way - for every 10 people who have a payment failure, you’re only recovering 3, leaving 7 to basically be flushed down the tubes.

After fixing up your delinquencies, I’d start to optimize annual payments. As the data indicates, those companies with more annual customers see lower churn, sometimes 5x lower, mainly because these customers have one purchasing decision per year versus 12 per year. 


Click to enlarge

This obviously won’t hack your way out of not having a great product, but it certainly will help if you already have the right foundation.

Next is a bit more difficult to implement, meaning it’s not a quick fix, but one of the highest impact shifts you can make is utilizing a value metric in your pricing strategy. A value metric is what you charge for - per user, per 100 visits, per 1,000 videos - could be a whole host of things.

Those companies utilizing a value metric tend to see half the gross churn of their feature differentiated counterparts.


Click to enlarge

This is mainly because with a value metric your users are paying for what they’re using and presumably if they’re using more, they’ll pay more. If they’re using less, they’ll pay less. Most importantly though, they’re paying for the value they’re receiving, so there isn’t a reason to churn.

Ultimately, your gross churn is an incredibly tricky problem to attack that no amount of tactics is going to solve. Yet, there are very mechanical pieces of churn and classic positioning strategies with value metrics and annuals that can help you stack the deck and compound the churn reduction value that your product team is already implementing.

Well, that's all for now. If you have a question, ship me an email or video to and if you got value here or on any other week of the report, we appreciate any and all shares on Twitter and LinkedIn. That’s how we measure if we should keeping doing this or not. We’ll see you next week. 

By Neel Desai

Product Lead, ProfitWell

Subscription market insights you won't find anywhere else.